Vancouver Mayoral Candidate Debate on Homelessness, Housing, and Mental Health: No easy answers.

Those who know me know that I’m a bit of a political wonk. Not obsessive or a junkie, but I certainly like to discuss the issues and consider new opinions. You couple that with an upcoming mayoral election in my new home city of Vancouver, well you know that my ears have been tuned into a bit.

Okay the first thing I had to figure out was the whole NPA, COPE, and Vision deal as far as political spectrum goes. That out of the way, well I’ve started to ponder this election a bit (one of the 4 I’ll have voted in this election season).

I had a chance to both listen to and speak with Vision candidate (centre-left) Gregor Robertson at Launch Party V last month and was impressed with his ideas. Peter Ladner I didn’t know too much about, but as the NPA candidate (right), I could guess his stance on a lot of issues.

Last night I was told by the Vision Team that there was going to be a debate that night on affordable housing, homelessness, and mental health issues just around the corner from me. I couldn’t very well pass that up, now could I?

Housing and homelessness have been on my mind a lot recently. I look at the people on the street in the Downtown Eastside and wonder what will becoming of them come the 2010 Olympics. I look at the cost of places to live close to the core of where the Vancouver tech community has set most of their roots (Gastown and Yaletown). I see buildings in decay and wonder why they couldn’t be renovated into housing.

Funny enough, those same questions are on the minds of a lot of people in this city because every one of them was touched on last night.

yvrmayoraldebate-71

In the midst on trying to capture pictures I wasn’t always able to focus on the discussion, but the tenor I caught. The mannerisms I caught. yvrmayoraldebate-96Peter Ladner was not a dynamic figure. I took hundreds of pictures of him last night and he has one expression, something I’d call a detached dour. Gregor Robertson I found to be a far more dynamic figure in his passion and discussion of the issues. Are this just surficial judgments that have no bearing on a campaign? Maybe, but a charismatic leader can inspire and lead people. He can challenge people.

For the meat of the discussion, frankly there are no easy answers to any of these questions. Both men agreed that money would be needed to work on the problems. Mr. Robertson pledged to end street homelessness by 2015. Mr. Ladner continued on NPA pledges to build more affordable housing, but he seemed to waver on exactly where that housing might be.

The Olympic Village’s transformation into housing for the rest of us, well it sounds like not as much of it is going to be something that either the poor or middle class will be able to afford.

Contrary to what the Globe and Mail says, this I feel is the core issue that separates the candidates. yvrmayoraldebate-95I see Gregor Robertson having a vision of Vancouver that will allow more people to be able to afford to live closer to Downtown if not in Downtown. I see Gregor Robertson being a man who has the passion and ability to connect with people, the people who are working and building a newer, better Vancouver.

I look at the tech community here, we’re young, damn-freakin’-scary smart, and passionate about what we do. We’re putting Vancouver on the map. I don’t see Peter Ladner paying much attention to us.

Peter Ladner certainly is carrying the baggage of the NPA’s past. He isn’t backing down on that, I didn’t hear him back peddle too much. Seems like a lot of more let the market figure it all out policy.

Yeah, that’s turned out to be a real winner of a strategy for the global economy hasn’t it?

Both parties/candidate put up rather sparse (okay not very good) blog posts: VisionPeter Ladner, but I’d like to continue the lively discussion we had on Twitter about this.

Please step up to the microphone placed in the centre aisle…

While you’re thinking, here is a slide show of some of the pictures I took from last night:

© Tris Hussey, 2008. Vancouver-based event and portrait photographer. Check out my photography portfolio for examples of my work.

  • Mike Meneer

    Since you say you are a policy wonk, I would suggest researching Mr. Robertson’s record on homelessness in Victoria. Why during his tenure in Victoria did he continually vote against funding to address homelessness?

    Some examples:

    He voted against:
    – the Province’s quadrupling of their housing budget which is helping Vancouver to build 3,800 new social housing units

    – funding to purchase 17 SROs in Vancouver that the city is now partnering with the province to develop

    – significant investments in emergency shelter funding that more than doubled capacity and enabled shelters to stay open 24/7

    It’s not enough to say he was in the opposition and had to vote against the ruling Liberals. There is such a thing as voting your conscience.

  • Mike Meneer

    Since you say you are a policy wonk, I would suggest researching Mr. Robertson’s record on homelessness in Victoria. Why during his tenure in Victoria did he continually vote against funding to address homelessness?

    Some examples:

    He voted against:
    – the Province’s quadrupling of their housing budget which is helping Vancouver to build 3,800 new social housing units

    – funding to purchase 17 SROs in Vancouver that the city is now partnering with the province to develop

    – significant investments in emergency shelter funding that more than doubled capacity and enabled shelters to stay open 24/7

    It’s not enough to say he was in the opposition and had to vote against the ruling Liberals. There is such a thing as voting your conscience.

  • http://billtieleman.blogspot.com/ Bill Tieleman

    Thanks very much Tris for your excellent photography! I wasn’t able to attend but feel like I was there as a result of your pictures and words.

    I’m in the unusual position of knowing both Peter and Gregor quite well and they are both good people. But I am supporting Gregor for mayor because I believe he is completely committed to fighting the worst issue facing our beautiful city – homelessness.

    I am very pleased that over 1000 people came out to the event – I think that it shows our citizens want to do something about this terrible problem that shouldn’t exist in a city as wealthy as Vancouver.

    I’m sorry that Peter Ladner’s public relations officer Michael Meneer wishes to attempt to spin Gregor Robertson’s position on your website. Anyone who knows Gregor understands that he would only vote against legislation in Victoria because it didn’t go far enough to deal with the homelessness problem, not because he opposed it.

    I could give many examples of where Peter Ladner has not done enough at City Hall but that’s not the point. I have no doubt that both Peter and Gregor want to see and end to the homelessness epidemic in Vancouver – I just believe that one of them sees it as more important – and that’s why I’m supporting Gregor Robertson.

    Thanks again – some really great pictures of a lot of people I know and others I don’t.

    Bill Tieleman´s last blog post..Is that really it? Premier Gordon Campbell’s free-time political broadcast shows lack of common sense in lame approach to fiscal crisis

  • http://billtieleman.blogspot.com/ Bill Tieleman

    Thanks very much Tris for your excellent photography! I wasn’t able to attend but feel like I was there as a result of your pictures and words.

    I’m in the unusual position of knowing both Peter and Gregor quite well and they are both good people. But I am supporting Gregor for mayor because I believe he is completely committed to fighting the worst issue facing our beautiful city – homelessness.

    I am very pleased that over 1000 people came out to the event – I think that it shows our citizens want to do something about this terrible problem that shouldn’t exist in a city as wealthy as Vancouver.

    I’m sorry that Peter Ladner’s public relations officer Michael Meneer wishes to attempt to spin Gregor Robertson’s position on your website. Anyone who knows Gregor understands that he would only vote against legislation in Victoria because it didn’t go far enough to deal with the homelessness problem, not because he opposed it.

    I could give many examples of where Peter Ladner has not done enough at City Hall but that’s not the point. I have no doubt that both Peter and Gregor want to see and end to the homelessness epidemic in Vancouver – I just believe that one of them sees it as more important – and that’s why I’m supporting Gregor Robertson.

    Thanks again – some really great pictures of a lot of people I know and others I don’t.

    Bill Tieleman´s last blog post..Is that really it? Premier Gordon Campbell’s free-time political broadcast shows lack of common sense in lame approach to fiscal crisis

  • http://www.trishussey.com/ Tris Hussey

    Mike you bring up an excellent point. Does the Westminster system of parliament really allow for votes of conscience? Even if it were a free vote, could you vote for increasing daycare space while also allowing for clear cutting of forests?

    I believe Gregor was asked about those particular votes and that perhaps those bills also contained unconscionable items?

    Personally I was more swayed and moved by Gregor’s stance and passion.

  • http://www.trishussey.com/ Tris Hussey

    Mike you bring up an excellent point. Does the Westminster system of parliament really allow for votes of conscience? Even if it were a free vote, could you vote for increasing daycare space while also allowing for clear cutting of forests?

    I believe Gregor was asked about those particular votes and that perhaps those bills also contained unconscionable items?

    Personally I was more swayed and moved by Gregor’s stance and passion.

  • http://www.trishussey.com/ Tris Hussey

    Bill, thank you very much. I had a hard time picking through all the pictures to choose those few (there are almost 600 that made the first cut).

    The people of the audience, the panelists, and the moderator, I feel made the debate a complete success.

    I would also say that I feel that Gregor’s plans and policies have more heart and perhaps will encourage a richer downtown Vancouver.

  • http://www.trishussey.com/ Tris Hussey

    Bill, thank you very much. I had a hard time picking through all the pictures to choose those few (there are almost 600 that made the first cut).

    The people of the audience, the panelists, and the moderator, I feel made the debate a complete success.

    I would also say that I feel that Gregor’s plans and policies have more heart and perhaps will encourage a richer downtown Vancouver.

  • http://www.votevision.ca Kevin

    Thanks Tris for posting those pictures! I’d also encourage you to check out the Vision platform at http://www.votevision.ca, and compare Gregor’s plan for dealing with homelessness and affordable housing with Peter and the NPA’s plan at http://www.npavancouver.ca.

  • http://www.votevision.ca Kevin

    Thanks Tris for posting those pictures! I’d also encourage you to check out the Vision platform at http://www.votevision.ca, and compare Gregor’s plan for dealing with homelessness and affordable housing with Peter and the NPA’s plan at http://www.npavancouver.ca.

  • Pingback: Tweet, tweet irony in Vancouver’s mayoral race | Citizen Journalism | A View from the Isle

TrisHusseyDotCom is Stephen Fry proof thanks to caching by WP Super Cache